Pipgrove

Added Sugar vs Natural Sugar: What Is the Difference?

Added sugar vs natural sugar explained in plain words: what counts as added, why fruit and milk are different, how to spot added sugar on a label, and how much is too much.

By the Pipgrove team. , 5 min read.

"Natural sugar" and "added sugar" show up on labels, in headlines and in diet advice, and it is easy to come away thinking one is good and one is poison. The truth is calmer and more useful. Here is what the difference really is, why it matters, and how to spot each one in your kitchen.

The short answer

Natural sugar is the sugar that is already inside a whole food: fructose in an apple, lactose in plain milk, a little sugar in carrots or tomatoes.

Added sugar is sugar put into a food or drink during processing, cooking or at the table: the sugar in soda, cookies, flavoured yogurt, ketchup, sweetened coffee, and the spoon you stir into tea.

Chemically, your body breaks both down into the same few simple sugars. The difference is not the molecule. It is the package the sugar comes in and how much of it you end up eating.

Why the package matters

A medium apple has a decent amount of sugar, but it also has water, fibre and a lot of chewing. It takes a few minutes to eat, it fills you up, and very few people eat four in a row.

A can of regular cola has around 39 g of sugar, close to ten teaspoons, with no fibre and nothing to chew. You can drink it in two minutes and still feel ready for lunch. You can see what that looks like in cubes in our post on how much sugar is in a Coke.

That is why health groups set limits for added sugar and not for whole fruit. Fibre, water and protein slow you down and make it hard to overdo it. Added sugar slips in easily, often in foods that do not even taste very sweet.

Try it: added or natural?

Tap a food to see whether its sugar counts as added. Some of them surprise people.

What counts as added sugar

On US food labels, "added sugars" includes sugars and syrups added during processing, sugar from honey and syrups, and sugar from concentrated fruit or vegetable juice beyond what you would expect from the same amount of plain juice (FDA). In plain terms, all of these count as added when they go into a food:

"Raw", "organic" and "natural" on the front of the pack do not change this. Organic cane sugar is still added sugar.

Where the WHO draws the line

The World Health Organization uses a slightly wider term, free sugars: all sugars added to foods plus the sugars naturally present in honey, syrups and fruit juices. It recommends keeping free sugars below 10% of your daily energy, and ideally below 5% (WHO guideline, 2015).

The practical difference is fruit juice. Even 100% juice with nothing added counts as free sugar for the WHO, because juicing removes most of the fibre and makes it easy to drink a lot. A glass of orange juice is not the same as eating an orange.

How much added sugar is too much?

The American Heart Association suggests no more than about 25 g a day for most women and 36 g for most men (AHA). The Dietary Guidelines for Americans say to keep added sugars below 10% of daily calories.

There is no similar limit for sugar in whole fruit, vegetables or plain milk. If you want to see where your day lands, our daily sugar calculator adds it up in a few taps.

How to read a label in 20 seconds

  1. Find the Nutrition Facts panel. Under "Total Sugars" there is a line that says "Includes Xg Added Sugars". That number is the one that counts toward your limit.
  2. Compare it with the limit. 12 g of added sugar in a yogurt is about half of the 25 g suggestion for women.
  3. Scan the ingredient list. Ingredients are listed by weight. If sugar or a syrup is in the first three, sugar is a main ingredient. Several different sweeteners spread through the list is another clue.
  4. Ignore front-of-pack words. "No refined sugar", "naturally sweetened" and "made with real fruit" do not mean low in added sugar.

Outside the US, labels often show only total sugars. Then the ingredient list is your best tool: a plain yogurt with only milk and cultures has natural sugar only; a fruit yogurt with "sugar" or "fruit concentrate" listed has added sugar too.

Common mix-ups

"Fruit has too much sugar." Whole fruit is one of the easiest ways to handle a sweet craving, and it does not count toward added sugar limits. If you have diabetes, your care team may give you personal guidance on portions. For everyone else, fruit is a friend. See what to eat when craving sugar for ideas.

"Honey is the healthy sugar." Honey has a few trace compounds, but in the amounts people eat it behaves much like table sugar and counts as added sugar.

"Dried fruit is the same as fresh." It is still whole fruit with fibre, but without the water it is very easy to eat a lot. Keep it to a small handful.

"Sugar-free means no sugar at all." Sugar-free products may use sweeteners instead. That is a separate topic; they do not count as added sugar on labels.

A simple way to use this

You do not need to fear sugar or track every gram. A calm approach works better:

When to talk to a doctor

If you have diabetes, prediabetes or take medication that affects blood sugar, ask your doctor or a dietitian how sugar from fruit and drinks fits your plan. The same goes if you have a history of disordered eating, where label reading can sometimes become stressful rather than helpful.

Pipgrove helps you cut back on added sugar without the guilt: an SOS button for cravings, a garden that grows with every lower-sugar day, and a kind letter each morning.

Quick answers

Is natural sugar better than added sugar?

Your body handles the sugar molecules in much the same way. The difference is the package: sugar inside whole fruit, vegetables and plain milk comes with water, fibre, protein and nutrients, and it is hard to eat a lot of it quickly. Added sugar usually arrives in large amounts with little else.

Does sugar in fruit count toward the daily limit?

No. The American Heart Association limits and the US Added Sugars line on food labels are about sugar added during processing or cooking, not sugar that is naturally in whole fruit. Fruit juice is a grey area: the WHO counts it as free sugar.

Is honey added sugar?

Yes, when you add it to food or drinks. Honey, maple syrup, agave and coconut sugar are all counted as added sugar, even though they sound natural.

How do I know if a food has added sugar?

In the US, check the "Includes Xg Added Sugars" line on the Nutrition Facts label. Also scan the ingredients for words like syrup, cane, nectar, honey, or anything ending in -ose.

Keep reading